The Promotional Products Horror Show: Tales from the "I'll Just Do It Myself" Files
- Florida Custom Merch
- 3 hours ago
- 8 min read
So you've decided to order promotional pens online. How hard could it be, right? You're a smart, capable business owner who's navigated far more complex challenges than slapping your logo on a writing instrument. Besides, you've successfully ordered things on Amazon before. You've even mastered the self-checkout at the grocery store. Clearly, you're qualified to handle this.
Spoiler alert: You're not. And I'm about to tell you why, with the kind of gentle honesty usually reserved for telling someone they have spinach in their teeth at a business dinner.
The Great Screen Deception of 2024
Picture this: You're sitting at your desk, feeling like a marketing genius. You've found the perfect pen online. You upload your logo with the confidence of someone who's watched half a YouTube tutorial. The digital proof arrives, and there it is on your gorgeous 27-inch monitor, looking absolutely magnificent. Your logo is crisp. Your phone number is readable. Your tagline "We Mean Business" is prominently displayed. You click approve with the same satisfaction you feel when perfectly parallel parking.
Three weeks later, a box arrives. You tear it open with the excitement of a kid on Christmas morning. You pull out a pen and... squint. Then squint harder. Then grab your reading glasses. Then turn on every light in the room. Your logo has apparently gone into the witness protection program. Your phone number requires a magnifying glass and divine intervention to read. And your tagline? It now reads "We M Bu" because the rest wandered off the edge of the pen like lemmings off a cliff.
Congratulations! You've just ordered 500 pens that require an optometrist's appointment to decipher. Your grandmother can't read them. Your customers definitely can't read them. Even you can't read them, and you know what they're supposed to say.
The Six-Point Font Incident (Or: How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love Microscopes)
Let's talk about six-point font for a moment. For those unfamiliar with typography (which, spoiler alert, is most people ordering promotional products), six-point font is what ants would use if they published newspapers. It's what appears at the bottom of pharmaceutical ads right before the spokesperson reminds you that death is a possible side effect.
Some promotional product companies will cheerfully print your information in six-point font on a pen. Not because they hate you personally, but because you never asked them not to. They figure if you approved the proof, you must have really, really good eyesight. Or maybe you're planning to distribute these pens exclusively to eagles, who can spot a rabbit from two miles away.
The result? You've created the world's first promotional product that requires its own promotional product—a magnifying glass with your logo on it, so people can read the pen with your logo on it. It's promotional inception, and not in a good way.
The Color Catastrophe Chronicles
Here's another fun adventure in the "what could possibly go wrong" theme park of DIY promotional products. You've chosen a beautiful pen in what the website calls "Ocean Blue." On your screen, it looks exactly like your brand color. Perfect match! You're basically a color-matching savant.
The pens arrive. They are indeed blue. But calling them "Ocean Blue" is generous. They're more "Blue Raspberry Slushie That's Been Sitting in the Sun." Or perhaps "Expired Blueberry Yogurt." Definitely not the sophisticated azure that represents your professional brand.
But wait, there's more! You decided to print your logo in what appeared online as a lovely gold. In reality, it's more of a "baby food squash" color. And against the weird blue background, it's about as visible as a chameleon at a chameleon convention.
You now own 1,000 pens that look like they were designed by someone who's only heard colors described over a bad phone connection. Your CFO is going to love explaining this line item in the budget meeting.
The Artwork Adventure (Subtitle: When "High Resolution" Is Relative)
You created your logo in Microsoft Word. It looks great! Well, it looks great in Microsoft Word. You save it as a JPEG, because that's an image file, right? Problem solved!
Except the promotional products company receives what can only be described as a pixelated mess that looks like it's being viewed through a shower door. But because they're trying to be helpful and you seemed really confident about this, they print it anyway. You approved the proof, after all, even though you were looking at it on your phone while walking the dog.
The result looks less like your professional logo and more like abstract art. If you squint and tilt your head, you can almost make out what it's supposed to be. Your company name now has that trendy "8-bit video game" aesthetic. Very retro. Very... unintentional.
The Spelling Bee Nightmare
Here's a true classic: You proofread your artwork three times. Your assistant proofread it twice. Your spouse even looked at it. Everyone agreed it was perfect. You sent it off with pride.
The products arrive, and there it is, immortalized in 500 glossy water bottles: "Profesional Services." Or "Your Trusted Partnr." Or my personal favorite, "Excelence in Everything We Do."
The proofreading curse strikes again. That's because on your large, beautiful screen, your brain autocorrected what your eyes were seeing. On the actual product, there's no autocorrect. Just a permanent monument to that one letter you didn't notice was missing, distributed to all your most important clients.
At least you're consistent in your excelence.
The "One Size Fits All" Delusion
You ordered t-shirts! Great idea. Everyone loves t-shirts. You selected "Adult Large" because that seems like a safe, middle-of-the-road choice. Most people wear large, right?
The shirts arrive. They fit exactly one person in your office: Dave from accounting, who is precisely 5'10", 180 pounds, and has the body proportions of a mannequin. For everyone else, they're either muumuus or compression garments. Your petite receptionist could use hers as a dress. Your tall warehouse manager looks like he's wearing a crop top.
But you got a great per-unit price on those 200 identical shirts! That's why you now have 199 Large t-shirts being used as cleaning rags, dog beds, and "someday these might fit me" wishful thinking storage.
The Mysterious Case of the Wandering Logo
You very carefully specified where you wanted your logo on the tote bags: centered on the front. Crystal clear instruction, right?
The bags arrive with your logo placed... somewhere. Front-ish. Sort of centered if you account for cosmic drift. One bag has it slightly left. Another has it slightly right. A third appears to have it located based on the printer's interpretation of abstract expressionism.
Turns out "centered" means different things to different people. Also turns out that bulk manufacturing involves human beings, machines with moods, and what can only be described as artistic interpretation. Your beautiful, coordinated order now looks like it was produced by five different companies who've never met each other.
The Material Misunderstanding
The website said "premium quality." The description used words like "luxurious" and "sophisticated." The price point suggested you were getting something nice.
What arrived can best be described as "aggressively budget." The pens feel like they might disintegrate if you sneeze near them. The tote bags have the structural integrity of tissue paper. The mugs are so thin you can practically see through them when held up to light.
You've basically purchased promotional products from the dollar store's clearance section, except you paid not-dollar-store prices. Your "premium" giveaways are now items people will try to discreetly leave behind at your event like unwanted fruitcake at Christmas.
The Quantity Quandary
The website had a minimum order of 250 units. That seemed reasonable when you were clicking buttons online. After all, you have customers! You have prospects! You attend networking events!
The box arrives and you realize that 250 promotional items is approximately 247 more than you will realistically distribute in the next five years. Your office now looks like a promotional products warehouse. Your car trunk is full of them. You've started leaving them with the tip at restaurants. You're considering giving them out at Halloween instead of candy.
Turns out you wildly overestimated both your networking capacity and your storage space. Also turns out your garage is now where promotional products go to contemplate their purpose in life.
Why Experts Exist (And Why Your Pride Shouldn't Stop You from Using Them)
Here's the thing: None of this makes you stupid. It makes you human. It makes you someone who thought they could figure out something outside their expertise because the internet made it look easy. The internet lies. The internet lies a lot.
Promotional products professionals exist for the same reason you exist in your profession. They've made all these mistakes already, usually with their own money. They know that six-point font is a war crime. They understand that "Ocean Blue" is more of a suggestion than a guarantee. They can tell you're about to order way too many items before you commit to storing them in your guest bedroom.
They've learned through painful, expensive experience what works, what doesn't, and what will make you want to fake your own death and move to a country without promotional products. They know which suppliers are reliable and which ones operate out of someone's garage with a heat press they bought at a yard sale.
Most importantly, they know which questions to ask—the ones you don't even know exist. Questions like "What's the actual imprint size in inches?" and "Can you guarantee PMS color matching?" and "What's your policy on spelling errors I didn't catch?" These aren't questions that occur to first-time buyers, which is exactly the problem.
The Expert Difference: More Than Just Avoiding Disasters
A promotional products expert doesn't just prevent catastrophes (though that alone is worth the investment). They actually help you look good. They guide you toward products that make sense for your audience. They suggest alternatives you'd never find on page 47 of a Google search. They make your logo look professional instead of like something created during a power outage.
They're also your advocate when things go wrong. Because sometimes, despite everyone's best efforts, things do go wrong. The difference is that when you're working with an expert, they handle it. They deal with the supplier, negotiate the reprint, expedite the replacement, and shield you from the nightmare of international customer service phone calls.
When you go it alone, you get to spend your valuable time explaining to someone in a distant call center why "Profesional" is spelled incorrectly, why yes, you're sure, and no, it's not a regional variation.
The Bottom Line (In More Ways Than One)
Ordering promotional products yourself might seem like a cost-saving measure. But when you factor in the mistakes, the reprints, the unusable items gathering dust in your storage closet, and the time you spend trying to fix everything, it's not actually cheaper. It's just more frustrating.
Plus, there's the opportunity cost of looking like an amateur. When you hand someone a pen they can't read, a t-shirt that doesn't fit, or a tote bag that falls apart, what are you really promoting? Probably not the professional, detail-oriented image you were going for.
Hiring an expert isn't admitting defeat. It's acknowledging that other people have invested time and energy into mastering skills you haven't, just like your customers acknowledge that you're the expert in your field. It's smart business. It's efficient. And it's way less likely to result in 500 pens that require a microscope and good lighting to read.
So save yourself the horror story. Save yourself the storage crisis. Save yourself from ever having to explain to your boss why you ordered XXL mouse pads instead of XL t-shirts because the abbreviations looked similar and you were ordering at midnight.
Call an expert. Let them do what they do best. And focus your energy on what you do best—which is definitely not deciphering the mysterious world of imprint methods, PMS color matching, and minimum order quantities.
Your future self, staring at a box of actually readable, correctly spelled, properly sized promotional products, will thank you.
Trust me on this. I've seen things. Promotional product things. Things that cannot be unseen.
With so many options available, choosing the right branded promotional item can be overwhelming. Since 2016, we, at Florida Custom Merch, have helped numerous businesses achieve success through the use of custom branded promotional merchandise. Hiring an expert can help you select the perfect item, save time and money, and, most importantly, maximize your results.
Thank you for reading! We hope you found this article helpful!
Most Popular Types of Custom Merch
(click on image to get more info)
