Why Testing Your Branded Merchandise Matters: Lessons from Flower-Shaped Highlighters
- Florida Custom Merch
- Sep 17
- 6 min read
At Florida Custom Merch, our mission is simple: to help businesses make a memorable impression through quality custom branded merchandise. But “quality” isn’t just about how something looks online—it’s about how it performs, feels, and functions in the real world.
A perfect example of this principle recently came from a batch of multi-color, flower-shaped highlighters that we were considering for distribution to our clients and prospects. On paper, these highlighters were adorable—bright, cheerful colors, an eye-catching flower shape, and printed with our logo. They seemed like the perfect giveaway item for trade shows, client gifts, or employee swag. But as any experienced merch professional knows, appearances can be deceiving.
The Importance of Testing Samples
Before offering any item to our clients, we take a rigorous approach: we test, inspect, and evaluate each product in person. It’s a step that may seem unnecessary, especially when you’ve seen dozens of beautiful online photos, but it’s absolutely critical.
For these flower-shaped highlighters, we ordered a set of samples to check everything from color vibrancy to functionality. It turns out that one color—green—was inconsistent. Some of the highlighters had dried-out green ink. Not all of them, and it seemed random, but the issue was significant: roughly one in three had a non-functioning green tip.
Now, you might think, “Isn’t that minor? People can still use the other colors.” But in branded merchandise, minor flaws send a big message. When a client receives a defective or partially functional item, it reflects not just on the product itself but also on the brand it represents. If we had shipped those highlighters without testing, the message would have been: “We care enough to put our name on something cute, but not enough to ensure it works.” That’s not the message we want to convey, and it’s certainly not the message our clients want to send to their customers.
What We Learned from This Experience
This experience reinforced several critical principles about branded merchandise:
Appearance isn’t everything. A product may look perfect online, but until it’s physically tested, you don’t know if it meets functional expectations. Color vibrancy, materials, printing quality, and even shelf-life of inks or adhesives can vary widely between suppliers.
Random defects can happen. Even products that seem perfectly manufactured can have inconsistencies. In our case, the green highlighters were intermittently dried out. Without hands-on inspection, these issues are easy to overlook.
Sample testing protects your reputation. By taking the time to evaluate products before distribution, we prevent situations where clients or prospects receive defective merchandise. That’s a small investment of time that saves significant embarrassment, frustration, and wasted marketing dollars.
Our Testing Process
When we evaluate a potential product, we don’t just glance at it. Our process includes:
Functional testing: Ensuring each item performs as intended. Highlighters must highlight, pens must write smoothly, drinkware must hold liquid without leaking, and tech gadgets must operate correctly.
Visual inspection: Checking colors, printing, and finishes. A logo should be sharp, centered, and legible; colors should match expectations.
Durability evaluation: Some items may look great initially but can show wear or defects quickly if used. Testing ensures longevity aligns with your brand promise.
Shelf-life considerations: Certain items, like highlighters or other ink-based products, can dry out over time. Our experience helps us predict which products are more likely to perform well over weeks or months, not just on the first day they arrive.
By doing all this, we ensure that any product we recommend is something we would confidently hand out ourselves.
Why This Matters for Your Business
The flower-shaped highlighter scenario highlights a broader point that applies to any business, not just ours. Expertise matters. You know your business better than anyone else—but when it comes to selecting branded merchandise, working with a partner who understands the nuances of product quality can save you time, money, and headaches.
Many businesses underestimate the importance of pre-testing products. They might assume that a high-quality supplier photo is sufficient or that minor defects are acceptable. But the reality is that your branded merchandise is an extension of your brand. Every item tells a story. A well-tested, high-quality item says, “We care about our customers, and we pay attention to the details.” A defective item says the opposite.
Our approach ensures that your merchandise works as intended and makes the impression you intend. We think about questions you might not consider:
Will the product still function after it sits in storage for weeks?
Will it hold up in the hands of a busy trade show audience?
Will every color, every detail, and every logo look as great in person as it does in a stock photo?
We’ve found that these considerations are what separate successful branded merchandise campaigns from those that fall flat. By testing, sampling, and evaluating products rigorously, we provide clients with confidence and peace of mind.
The Value of Experience
Testing the highlighters also reinforced the value of experience in this business. We’ve handled countless products over the years—pens, mugs, tech gadgets, bags, wearables, and more. Each category has its quirks. Some items fail because of manufacturing inconsistencies. Some fail because of storage conditions. Some fail because of improper usage.
By learning from each case, we’ve developed the expertise to spot potential problems before they reach our clients. That’s a level of insight that can’t be gained overnight or from online photos alone. It comes from doing the work, owning the business, and caring about the outcome for every client.
This principle applies broadly. Whatever business you’re in, your expertise is your advantage. Our expertise lies in branded merchandise, and we use it to save our clients time, money, and frustration. It’s why we stress testing and why we recommend ordering samples—even if it’s not a branded sample—to ensure the product meets your expectations.
Recommendations for Clients
Based on our recent experience with the flower-shaped highlighters, here’s what we advise businesses when selecting branded merchandise:
Order samples before committing. Even if you’re ordering a large quantity, a sample can reveal issues that photos or descriptions can’t.
Inspect every detail. Look for functionality, visual quality, durability, and even subtle factors like shelf-life.
Consider your audience. Certain products may appeal to some clients but not others. We can help recommend products based on your target audience and use case.
Factor in timing. Products like highlighters or other ink-based items can dry out over time. Be strategic about when you order, store, and distribute them.
Partner with experts. Working with a knowledgeable supplier ensures potential issues are caught early, not after they reach your customers.
Conclusion
At Florida Custom Merch, our goal is more than simply supplying products with a logo. We aim to provide solutions that reflect well on our clients’ brands. The story of the flower-shaped highlighters demonstrates that even the most charming products can have hidden flaws—but with careful testing, rigorous inspection, and thoughtful recommendations, those flaws can be caught before they ever reach your audience.
Every item we offer goes through this process because we understand that your brand is on the line. We help businesses select products that are not only visually appealing but also functional, durable, and appropriate for their audience. Our experience allows us to anticipate problems, avoid disappointments, and provide peace of mind.
Branded merchandise is a powerful marketing tool when executed correctly. By investing the time to test, inspect, and carefully select products, you ensure that every giveaway, trade show item, or client gift strengthens your brand rather than undermines it.
So the next time you see an online photo of a cute, colorful item, remember: it’s not just about how it looks—it’s about how it works in the real world. And that’s where expertise, testing, and thoughtful evaluation make all the difference.
With so many options available, choosing the right branded promotional item can be overwhelming. Since 2016, we, at Florida Custom Merch, have helped numerous businesses achieve success through the use of custom branded promotional merchandise. Hiring an expert can help you select the perfect item, save time and money, and, most importantly, maximize your results.
Thank you for reading! We hope you found this article helpful!
Most Popular Types of Custom Merch
(click on image to get more info)
